Should You Replace or Repair Your Deck?

If you’re running a business such as a café, corporate building, or retail space, you know how important it is to create a friendly and welcoming atmosphere for your customers and guests. Commercial decks, whether timber or composite, can help you achieve this goal. However, when your deck starts showing signs of wear and tear, you may have to make a tough decision: should you replace or repair your deck? Don’t worry because we’ll help you make the right choice for your business.

Understanding the Condition of Your Deck

The first thing you have to do is assess the current condition of your commercial deck. Look for signs of wear and tear, such as loose boards, visible rot, or termite damage. If these issues are localised and not indicative of a larger structural issue, repairs might be enough to extend the life of your timber or composite deck.

Option #1: Repair Your Deck

Repairing your deck can be cost-effective if the damage is minimal or confined to specific areas. The cost of wooden deck repair can vary widely, but common deck repairs like replacing damaged boards or fixing loose stairs can range from $150 to $300, significantly less than a full replacement. Also, repairs can often be completed more quickly than a replacement, causing minimal disruption to your daily business operations.

However, it’s essential to consider the long-term implications of repairs. If your deck requires frequent repairs or if the repairs are merely a temporary fix for deeper structural issues, the costs can add up over time. Don’t forget that these repair costs can also affect your ongoing timber deck maintenance expenses and schedule. You may have to seal and stain more frequently to prevent future damage.

More Considerations

To further help you decide whether to repair your wood deck, here is a quick list of its advantages and disadvantages:

The Pros of Repairing a Deck

Cost Savings: Picking repairs over a complete overhaul can be kinder to your budget. That’s an essential consideration if you’re watching your business expenditures closely.
Minimal Interruption: Professional commercial deck service providers often execute repairs so smoothly that your business operations barely skip a beat.
Quick Solution: If the damage is localised or minor, timber deck repairs can be a quick fix to keep your outdoor area safe and inviting.
Sustainability: Choosing to fix up your deck rather than tear it down can be seen as a sustainable choice, as it conserves resources and minimises waste.

The Drawbacks of Repairing a Deck

Short-Term Solution: Sometimes, repairs are nothing but a stopgap, particularly for decks that have seen better days or bear significant damage. You may need more maintenance work, which can add up financially over time.
Potential for Recurring Issues: Without tackling the root cause, you might find yourself in a loop of fixing the same issues, such as rot or instability. Over time, this cycle of repairs could prove pricier than a full deck replacement.
Missed Opportunities for Enhancement: Limiting your action to repairs means missing out on the chance to revamp your outdoor space with modern materials or a fresh design.

Option #2: Replace Your Deck

If your deck is showing its age or has suffered significant damage, it might be time to think about a full replacement. The cost of installing a new timber deck in Australia varies widely, from $3,600 to $11,500, influenced by factors like size and choice of materials. Despite the upfront investment, the benefits of a new deck—enhanced safety, aesthetic appeal, and higher property value—cannot be overlooked.

Deck replacement also offers the perfect opportunity to consider materials that promise greater durability and lower maintenance. Composite decking, for instance, is becoming a favourite among property owners for its long-lasting qualities and ease of care. Though initially more expensive than traditional wood, its resilience against wear and tear often makes it a more economical choice over time.

More Considerations

Still can’t decide whether to repair or replace your deck? Here is a quick rundown of the pros and cons of replacing a commercial deck:

The Benefits of Replacing Your Deck

Durability and Low Maintenance: Opting for new materials like millboard and other composite decking types can significantly extend your deck’s lifespan—up to 25 years with minimal upkeep.
Fresh Design and Modern Materials: A replacement allows you to refresh the deck’s look and functionality, aligning with the latest trends and operational requirements.
Boosts Property Value: A well-designed, modern deck can make your commercial space more appealing and functional, potentially increasing its market value.
Safety and Standards: Building a new deck to current codes undeniably enhances safety and ensures regulatory compliance.

The Disadvantages of Replacing Your Deck

Higher Upfront Costs: The initial expense of replacing a deck is considerably higher than simple repairs, which might strain the budgets of smaller businesses.
Operational Disruptions: Deck construction can interrupt your business, possibly necessitating temporary closure or resulting in lost revenue.
Environmental Concerns: The demolition and disposal of the old deck contribute to waste, though recycling or repurposing materials can mitigate this impact.
Project Complexity: Replacing a commercial deck is a comprehensive undertaking that demands meticulous planning and professional execution.

Let Us Help You Decide

Ultimately, deciding whether to repair or replace your wood deck depends on several factors. These include the extent of the damage, the age of the deck, your budget, and your long-term plans for the property. It’s advisable to consult with a professional who can assess the condition of your deck and provide a detailed cost analysis for both options. For instance, you can reach out to our expert team.

At Mathiou Services, we perform top-notch commercial deck repair and installation services throughout Australia. With over a decade of industry experience, we have successfully served more than 4,500 clients nationwide. Our team of experts is highly skilled in handling even the most complex deck repair projects, ensuring timely delivery of high-quality results without exceeding your budget.